The aim of this paper is to investigate the actual behaviours of companies listed on the Italian Stock Exchange as regards how they report comprehensive income (CI) in their financial statement. The study is based on the consolidated financial statements of 160 groups including industrial sectors. The research, one of the first in Italy to investigate the reasons behind the choices of accounting format to represent CI, shows that the majority of the selected sample has opted for maintaining two separate documents so distinguishing net income from comprehensive income. The mixed results obtained in the study suggest as that the choice of format for the CI is probably influenced by the Italian accounting tradition rather than the characteristics of income.


  • ALLEGRINI M. (2001), Concetti di reddito e conseguenti logiche di valutazione, Milano: Giuffrè.
  • ALLEGRINI M. and NINCI E. (2008), Novità in vista per gli schemi di bilancio: lo IAS 1 revised 2007, Amministrazione & Finanza, 9: 7-13.
  • AIMR (1993), Association for Investment Management and Research, Financial Accounting in the 1990s and Beyond; AIMR, Charlottesville, VA.
  • AZZALI S., FORNACIARI L. and PESCI C. (2010), The value relevance of the performance of listed Italian companies following the introduction of the IAS/IFRS, 4th edition of the Annual International Conference Globalization and Higher Education in Economics and Business Administration (GEBA), Alexandru Ioan Cuza University, Romania, 21-23 ottobre.
  • BEALE B. and DAVEY H. (1997), Comprehensive Income, Charted Accountants Journal, 76, 3:31-33.
  • BEALE B. and DAVEY H. (1999), Comprehensive Income: the perceived usefulness of total recognised revenues and expenses in new Zeland, Asian Review of Accounting, 7, 2:19-31.
  • BEALE B. and DAVEY H. (2000), The Nature and Origins of Comprehensive Income, in: S.B. Dahiya (ed.), The Current State of Business Disciplines, New Delhi: SpellBound Publications Ltd., 1: 81-100.
  • BEISLAND L.A. (2009), A Review of the Value Relevance Literature, The Open Business Journal, 2: 7-27.
  • BERTONI M., DE ROSA B. and MAFFEI M. (2007), Comprehensive income under IFRS: evidence from a cross-sectional analysis, 3rd EUFIN Workshop on Accounting in Europe, Paris, France.
  • BHAMORNSIRI S. and WIGGINS C. (2006), Comprehensive income disclosures, The CPA Journal, 71, 10: 54-56.
  • BIDDLE G.C. and CHOI J.H. (2006), Is Comprehensive Income Useful?, Journal of Contemporary Accounting and Economics, 2, 1: 1-32.
  • BORRA S. and DI CIACCIO A. (2008), Statistica. Metodologia per le scienze economiche e sociali, Milano: McGraw-Hill.
  • BRAGG V.E. (1997), Reporting Comprehensive Income, Florida CPA, September: 5-7.
  • BRIEF R.P. and PEASNELL K.V. (1996), Clean Surplus, A Link between Accounting and Finance, Garland Publishing Inc.
  • BRIMBLE M., HODGSON A. (2004), The Value Relevance of Comprehensive Income e Components for Industrial Firms, Working Paper, Griffith University, Brisbane, Australia.
  • CAHAN S.F., COURTNEAY S.M., GRONEWOLLER P.L. and UPTON D.R. (2000), Value-Relevance of Mandated Comprehensive Income Disclosures, Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 27, 9-10: 1272-1301.
  • CAMPBELL L., CRAWFORD D. and FRANZ D.R. (1999), How companies are complying with the Comprehensive Income disclosure requirements, The Ohio CPA Journal, 58, 1: 13-20.
  • CARLSON R., MOONEY K. and SCHWIEGER B. (1999), More Information on the Income Statement?, National Public Accountant, 44, 1: 50-53.
  • CHAMBERS D., LINSMEIER T.J., SHAKESPEARE C., SOUGIANNIS T. (2007), An Evaluation of SFAS nº 130 Comprehensive Income Disclosures, Review of Accounting Studies, 12, 4: 557-593.
  • CHENG A., CHEUNG J. and GOPALAKRISHNAN V. (1993), On the Usefulness of Operating Income, Net Income and Comprehensive Income in Explaining Security Returns, Accounting and Business Research, 23, 91: 195-203.
  • CONFALONIERI M. (2009), Alcune riflessioni sul fair value, Rivista Italiana di Ragioneria ed Economia Aziendale, 7/8: 411-423.
  • COURTEAU L. (2008), Valori di impresa e valori di bilancio, Milano: Franco Angeli.
  • D’ESTE C. and FELLEGARA A.M. (2009), Valore economico, fari value e reddito non realizzati. Prime evidenze empiriche della rendicontazione del comprehensive income in Italia, Financial Reporting, 4: 9-34.
  • DE CRISTOFARO T. and FALZAGO B. (2010), Il Comprehensive Income nelle relazioni semestrali 2009 delle società elettriche quotate. Alcune evidenze empiriche, Dasta working paper series, n. 22, Università “G. d’Annunzio”, Pescara.
  • DEVALLE A. (2010), Misurazione della performance nel bilancio IFRS. Comprehensive Income, dibattito internazionale e value relevance, Milano: Pearson.
  • DEZZANI F., BIANCONE P.P. and BUSSO D. (2010), Manuale IAS/IFRS, Milano: Ipsoa.
  • DHALIWAL D., SUBRAMANYAM K.R. and TREZEVANT R. (1999), Is comprehensive income superior to net income as a measure of firm performance?, Journal of Accounting and Economics, 26, 1-3: 43-67.
  • FERNÁNDEZ F.S. and CARRO M.M. (2009), Empirical Analysis Of The Impact Of Comprehensive Income On Basic Earnings Per Share For Spanish Companies Listed On Madrid Stock Exchange, International Business & Economics Research Journal, 8, 6: 7-24.
  • FERRARO O. and VELTRI S. (2012), A critical analysis of the empirical researches on Comprehensive Income value relevance, European Journal of Scientific Research, Vol. 76, n. 4, pp. 587-594.
  • FITZSIMMONS A.P. and THOMSON J.W. (1996), Reporting Comprehensive Income, Commercial Lending Review, 11, 4: 97-103.
  • GONCHAROV I. and HODGSON A.C. (2008), Comprehensive income in Europe: Valuation, prediction and conservatism issues, Annales Universitatis Apulensis Serie Economica, Faculty of Sciences, 1December 1918 University, Alba Iulia, 1, 10.
  • GREENE W.H. (2003), Econometric analysis. Fifth edition, New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
  • JORDAN C.E. and CLARK J. (2002), Comprehensive income: how is it being reported and what are its effects?, The Journal of Applied Business Research, 18, 2: 1-8.
  • KANAGARETNAM K., MATHIEU R. and SHEHATA M. (2009), Usefulness of Comprehensive Income Reporting in Canada. Journal Accounting Public Policy, 28: 349-365.
  • LIN S., RAMOND O. J. and CASTA J. (2007), Value Relevance of Comprehensive Income and Its Components: Evidence from Major European Capital Markets, American Accounting Association (AAA), International Accounting Section (IAS) Mid-Year Conference, 2-3 February 2007.
  • LUECKE R.W. and MEETING D.T. (1998), How Companies Report Income, Journal of Accountancy. 185, 5: 45.52.
  • MATTESICH R. (2002), The Theory of Clean Surplus and its Evolution: Survey and Recent Perspectives, Energia - Ineternational journal of Philosophy and Methodology of Economics, 1, 2: 9-46.
  • MCFADDEN D. (1974), Conditional Logit Analysis of Qualitative Choice Behaviour, in: Zarembka P. (ed. by) “Frontiers in Econometrics”, New York: Academic Press.
  • MECHELLI A. (2011), La value relevance del comprehensive income e dei suoi componenti: un’indagine sperimentale, Rivista Italiana di Economia Aziendale, 111, 3/4: 128- 142.
  • MELIS G., MELIS A. and PILI A. (2006), Fair Value and Stackeholder-Oriented Accounting Systems. Some evidences From Italy, Corporate Ownership and Control, 4, 1: 127-138.
  • PANDIT G.M. and PHILLIPS J.J. (2004), Comprehensive Income: reporting preferences of Public Companies, The CPA Journal, 74, 11: 40-41.
  • PANDIT G.M., RUBENFIELD A. and PHILLIPS J.J. (2006), Current NASDAQ Corporation methods of reporting Comprehensive income, Mid-American Journal of Business, 21: 13-19.
  • PETERSEN M.A. (2009), Estimating standard errors in finance panel data sets: comparing approaches, The Review of Financial Studies, 22, 1: 435-480.
  • PISANI M. (2007), La misura delle prestazioni nel bilancio di esercizio. Il Comprehensive income statement, Milano: FrancoAngeli.
  • PISANI M. (2011), La struttura del Comprehensive Income Statement: le indicazioni del progetto congiunto IAS-FASB Financial Statement Presentation, Financial Reporting, 4: 9-48.
  • POZZOLI M. (2007), La revisione dello IAS 1, Guida alla Contabilità&Bilancio, 16, Settembre, Il Sole 24 Ore.
  • QUAGLI A. (2008), La presentazione del bilancio secondo la nuova versione dello IAS 1, Revisione contabile, 82:72-90.
  • ROBERTS C. and WANG Y. (2009), Accounting harmonization and the value-relevance of dirty surplus accounting flows, Review of Accounting and Finance, 8, 4:340-368.
  • SPROUSE R.T. and MOONITZ M. (1962), A Tentative Set of Board Accounting Principles for Business Enterprises, Accounting Research Study, American Institute of Certified Public Accountants.
  • STEVENS M.G. (1997), The new prominence of comprehensive income, Practical Accountant, 30, 9: 59-62.
  • STOCK J.H. and WATSON M.W. (2009), Introduzione all’econometria, seconda edizione, Padova: Pearson.
  • TARCA A. (2006), Discussion of Isidro, O’Hanlon and Young, Abacus, 42, 3-4:345-353.
  • TOZZI I. (2009), Concordanze e discordanze tra varie nozioni di reddito d’impresa. Rivista Italiana di Ragioneria e di Economia Aziendale, 11/12: 671-680.
  • VAN CAUWENBERGE P. and DE BEELDE I. (2010), A critical note on empirical comprehensive income research, Betriebswirftschaftliche Forschung und Praxis, 62: 82-101.
  • VELTRI S. E FERRARO O. (2012), La value relevance del comprehensive income rispetto al net income. Un’analisi sulle società quotate in Italia, Financial Reporting, n. 3, pp. 9-29.
  • WHITTINGTON G. (2005), The adoption of international accounting standard in the European Union European Accounting Review, 14, 1: 127-153.
Chiudi [X]

Acquista l'articolo

Inserisci i tuoi dati affinché un funzionario di Giuffrè possa contattarti per perfezionare i termini dell’acquisto

Campi obbligatori*