I PREZZI DI TRASFERIMENTO INTERNAZIONALI: UN’INDAGINE EMPIRICA SULLE IMPRESE OPERANTI IN ITALIA

Abstract

This paper investigates income shifting activities via International Transfer Pricing (ITP) practices carried out by companies located in Italy. We adopt an indirect method, based on the comparison of the performances between foreign controlled companies (FCCs) and domestically-controlled companies (DCCs), to show that FCCs outperform their DCCs counterparts, especially in the case of small and medium enterprises. This result holds after controlling for differences in size, sector, geographical location, capital structure and investment policies. Overall, our findings contrast with previous empirical evidence on ITP practices in other countries and suggest further research to verify whether the search for comparables as prescribed by the OECD transfer pricing guidelines might guarantee fairness and reliability for taxpayers or it is fallacious in principle.

References

  • AA. VV., I prezzi di trasferimento. Determinanti e metodologie di calcolo, Egea, 1999
  • BIANCO M., CASAVOLA P., Italian corporate governance: Effects on financial structure, European economic review, 43 (4-6)/1999, p. 1057 e ss.
  • BRUNI G., Contabilità del valore per aree strategiche d’affari, Giappichelli, 1999.
  • BUCKLEY P.J., CASSON M.C., The internalisation theory of the multinational enterprise: A review of the progress of a research agenda after 30 years, Journal of International Business Studies, 40/2009, p. 1563 e ss.
  • CAVES R.E., Multinational Enterprise and Economic Analysis, University Press, 1996.
  • CODA V., La determinazione dei redditi sezionali con particolare riguardo alle aziende di credito, in Scritti in onore di Giordano dell’Amore. Saggi monetari e creditizi, Vol. 1, Giuffrè, 1969, p. 699 e ss.
  • COLLINS J.H., KEMSLEY D., LANG M., Cross-jurisdictional income shifting and earnings valuation, Journal of Accounting Research, 2/1998, p. 209 e ss.
  • COLLINS J.H., KEMSLEY D., SHACKELFORD D.A., Transfer pricing and the persistent zero taxable income of foreign-controlled U.S. corporations, Journal of the American Taxation Association, 19 (suppl.)/1997, p. 68 e ss.
  • COMPAGNO C., La valorizzazione delle transazioni nei rapporti interdivisionali: profili tecnici, assetti strutturali e criteri operativi, Cedam, 1986.
  • CRAIN T.L., STITTS R.H., A comparison of gross-profit margins between foreign-controlled domestic corporations, Journal of International Accounting Auditing & Taxation 1/1994, p. 85 e ss.
  • CRAVENS K.S., SHEARON W.T., An outcome-based assessment of international transfer pricing policy, The International Journal of Accounting, 4/1996, p. 419 e ss.
  • DESAI M.A., DYCK A., ZINGALES L., Theft and taxes, Journal of financial economics, 84 (3)/2007, p. 591 e ss.
  • DOMS, M.E., JENSEN, B., 1998. Comparing Wages, Skills, and Productivity between Domestically and Foreign Owned Manufacturing Establishments in the United States, in LIPSEY R.E, BALDWIN R.E., RICHARDSON J.D., Geography and ownership as bases for economic accounting, The University of Chicago Press, 1998, p. 235 e ss.
  • DUNNING J.H., American investment in British manufacturing industry, George Allen and Unwin, 1958.
  • EDEN L., Taxing Multinationals: Transfer Pricing and Corporate Income Taxation in North America, University of Toronto Press, 1998.
  • ECKAUS R.S., The North-South differential in Italian Economic Development, The Journal of Economic History, 3/1961, p. 285 e ss.
  • EMMANUEL C., MEHAFDI M., Transfer Pricing, Academic Press, 1994
  • EMMANUEL C., OTLEY D., MERCHANT K, Accounting for management control, Chapman & Hall, 1990.
  • EMMANUEL C., OYLERE P.B., Differences in the reported performances of foreign-controlled and domestically-controlled firms: some U.K. evidence, Journal of International Accounting, Auditing & Taxation 1/2002, p. 1 e ss.
  • FERRERO G., DEZZANI F., Manuale delle analisi di bilancio. Indici e flussi, Giuffrè, 1979.
  • GLOBERMAN S., RIES J.C, VERTINSKY I., The economic performance of foreign affiliates in Canada, The Canadian Journal of Economics, 27/1994, p. 143 e ss.
  • GRUBERT H., Another look at the low taxable income of foreign-controlled corporations in the United States, in Office of Tax Analysis (OTA), Working Paper No. 74, US Treasury Department, 1997.
  • GRUBERT H., MUTTI J., Taxes, tariffs and transfer pricing in multinational corporate decision making, Review of Economics and Statistics, 73/1991, p. 285 e ss.
  • GRUBERT H., GOODSPEED T., SWENSON, D., Explaining the low taxable income of foreign controlled companies, in GIOVANNINI. A., HUBBARD R.G., SLEMROD J., Studies in international taxation, NBER and University of Chicago, 1993, p. 237 e ss.
  • HARRIS D.G., The impact of U.S. tax law revision on multinational corporations, Journal of Accounting Research, 31 (suppl.)/1993, p. 111 e ss.
  • HARRIS D.G., MORCK R., SLEMROD J., YEUNG. B. Income shifting in U.S. multinational corporations, in GIOVANNINI. A., HUBBARD R.G., SLEMROD J., Studies in international taxation, NBER and University of Chicago, 1993, p. 277 e ss.
  • HINES J.R., RICE E.M., Fiscal paradise: foreign tax havens and American business, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1/1994, p. 149 e ss.
  • ISTITUTO NAZIONALE PER IL COMMERCIO ESTERO (ICE), L’Italia nell’economia internazionale, Rapporto ICE 2009-2010, 2011
  • JACOB J., Taxes and transfer pricing: income shifting and the volume of intrafirm transfers, Journal of Accounting Research, 2/1996, p. 301 e ss.
  • KIM, W.S., LYN E.O., FDI theories and the performance of foreign multinationals operating in the US, Journal of International Business Studies, 1/1990, p. 41 e ss.
  • KLASSEN K., LANG M., WOLFSON M. Geographic income shifting by multinational corporations in response to tax rate changes, Journal of Accounting Research, 31(suppl.)/ 1993, p. 141 e ss.
  • KOENKER R., HALLOCK K.F., Quantile Regression, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 4/2001, p. 43 e ss.
  • LANGLI J.C., SAUDAGARAN S.M., Taxable income differences between foreign and domestic controlled corporations in Norway, European Accounting Review, 4/2004, p. 713 e ss.
  • LEONARDI R., Regional development in Italy: social capital and the Mezzogiorno, Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 2/1995, p. 165 e ss.
  • LIN L., LEFEBVRE, C., KANTOR, J., Economic determinants of international transfer pricing and the related accounting issues, with particular reference to Asian specific countries, International Journal of Accounting, 28/1993, p. 49 e ss
  • MELIS G., Il bilancio d’esercizio come strumento di controllo della gestione, Giuffrè 2004.
  • MURA A, EMMANUEL C., Transfer pricing: Early Italian Contributions, Accounting, Business, and Financial History, 20/2010, p. 365 e ss,
  • MUSSELLI A, MUSSELLI A.C., Transfer pricing. I prezzi di trasferimento internazionali, Il Sole 24 Ore, 2011.
  • NICODEME G., Comparing Effective Corporate Tax Rates, Frontiers in Finance and Economics, 4(2)/2007, p. 102 e ss.
  • ONIDA P., Il bilancio di esercizio nelle imprese, Giuffrè, 1951.
  • OCSE (ORGANIZZAZIONE PER LA COOPERAZIONE E PER LO SVILUPPO ECONOMICO), Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations, OCSE Parigi 2010.
  • OCSE (ORGANIZZAZIONE PER LA COOPERAZIONE E PER LO SVILUPPO ECONOMICO), Transfer pricing: Keeping it at arm’s length, OECD Observer 230, January 2002 (Corrected 3 July 2008)
  • OYLERE P.B., EMMANUEL C., International transfer pricing and income shifting: evidence from the UK, European Accounting Review, 4/1998, p. 623 e ss.
  • PILATI M., Politiche dei prezzi di trasferimento: organizzazione e controllo nei quasimercati, Egea, 1990.
  • PODDIGHE F., L’azienda nella fase istituzionale, Plus, 2001
  • TYBOUT J.R., Manufacturing firms in developing countries: how well do they do, and why?, Journal of Economic Literature, 38 /2000, p. 11 e ss.
  • WHEELER J.E. An academic look at transfer pricing in a global economy, Tax Notes 4/1988, p. 87 e ss.
  • WHEELER J.E., Hearings on tax under-payments by foreign-owned US subsidiaries, Hearings before the Subcommittee on Ways and Means, United States House of Representatives, April, 1990, p. 1 e ss.
  • WHEELER J.E, WEBER R.P., A New Minimum Tax as a Solution to Inbound and Outbound Section 482 Problems, the Complexity of the Current, and the Need for More Tax Revenues, Tax Notes, 12/1990, p. 95 e ss.
  • WHENREIDER A.J., Profit shifting in the EU: evidence from Germany, International Tax and Public Finance, 3/2009, p. 281 e ss.
  • World Economic Forum, The global competitiveness report 2010-2011, Ginevra, 2010.
  • ZAPPA G., Le produzioni nell’economia delle imprese, Tomo 1, Giuffrè, 1956.
Close [X]

Buy the article

Cibo assum quidam at est, iusto tibique dissentiet eum ad. Te partem persius mentitum pri. Duo no commodo senserit. Ferri rebum debitis ea pri, timeam blandit rationibus te nam. Velit phaedrum interpretaris his id, mutat vidisse facilis eu pri.

Required fields are marked *

Authors

👤  Alessandro Mura
👤  Francesco Vallascas
👤  Clive Emmanuel