LE RIVALUTAZIONI DA LEGGI SPECIALI: L’EVIDENZA EMPIRICA NEI BILANCI DELLE IMPRESE ITALIANE

Abstract

Using the financial statements of a large sample of private Italian firms belonging to the manufacturing, commercial and service sector over the period 2003-2012, this paper shows that smaller firms with weaker solvency and liquidity conditions and a higher level of financial debts are more likely to revaluate their fixed assets when permitted by special laws. The relation between profitability and the accounting choice of revaluating appears changeable according to the specific fiscal conditions prescribed by each special law. These findings suggest that private Italian firms opportunistically revaluate their assets in order to show an increase in the firm’s wealth. The empirical evidence documented in this paper accords with the institutional context in which private Italian firms operate and with the features that characterise this revaluation practice. The more or less emphasised fiscal attractiveness and the strengthening of net assets of this accounting treatment appear particularly suitable to balance the potentially conflicting expectations of lenders and fiscal authorities. Nonetheless, these findings cast a dark shadow on the perspective that the "revaluation model”, at present only allowed by IAS/IFRS, is extended to all Italian firms.


References

  • Abstract: Using the financial statements of a large sample of private Italian firms belonging to the manufacturing, commercial and service sector over the period 2003-2012, this paper shows that smaller firms with weaker solvency and liquidity conditions and a higher level of financial debts are more likely to revaluate their fixed assets when permitted by special laws. The relation between profitability and the accounting choice of revaluating appears changeable according to the specific fiscal conditions prescribed by each special law. These findings suggest that private Italian firms opportunistically revaluate their assets in order to show an increase in the firm’s wealth. The empirical evidence documented in this paper accords with the institutional context in which private Italian firms operate and with the features that characterise this revaluation practice. The more or less emphasised fiscal attractiveness and the strengthening of net assets of this accounting treatment appear particularly suitable to balance the potentially conflicting expectations of lenders and fiscal authorities. Nonetheless, these findings cast a dark shadow on the perspective that the “revaluation model”, at present only allowed by IAS/IFRS, is extended to all Italian firms.
  • ALJINOVIĆ BARAĆ Z., ŠODAN S., Motives for Asset Revaluation Policy Choice in Croatia, Croatian Operational Research Review, 2/2011, pag. 60 e ss.
  • Assonime, circolare n. 23 del 12 giugno 2006, pag. 27 e segg.
  • BARLEV B., FRIED D., HADDAD J. R., LIVNAT J., Reevaluation of Revaluations: A Cross- Country Examination of the Motives and Effects on Future Performance, Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 34(7-8)/2007, pag. 1025 e ss.
  • BARTH M. E., CLINCH G., Revalued Financial, Tangible, and Intangible Assets: Associations with Share Prices and Non-Market-Based Value Estimates, Journal of Accounting Research, 36(supp)/1998, pag. 199 e ss.
  • BLACK E. L., SELLERS K. F., MANLY T. S., Earnings Management Using Asset Sales: An International Study of Countries Allowing Noncurrent Asset Revaluation, Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 25(9-10)/1998, pag. 1287 e ss.
  • BRANCIARI, S., MATTEUCCI, L., L’armonizzazione contabile internazionale: un’indagine sui gruppi industriali quotati al NYSE, Il risparmio, 47(5-6)/1999 pag. 745 e ss.
  • BROWN P., IZAN HY, LOH A. L., Fixed Asset Revaluations and Managerial Incentives, Abacus, 28(1)/1992, pag. 36 e ss.
  • CAPODAGLIO G., Le riserve di rivalutazione, Rivista Italiana di Ragioneria e di Economia Aziendale, 101(5-6)/2001, pag. 231 e ss.
  • CODA V., FRATTINI G., Valutazioni Di Bilancio: Principi Economici, Norme Civili, Norme Fiscali E Direttive Comunitarie, Libreria Universitaria, 1981.
  • COTTER J., Asset Revaluations and Debt Contracting, Abacus, 35(3)/1999, pag. 268 e ss.
  • COTTER J., ZIMMER I., Asset Revaluations and Assessment of Borrowing Capacity, Abacus, 31(2)/1995, pag. 136 e ss.
  • DE DOMINICIS U., I bilanci delle imprese nei periodi di oscillazione del valore della moneta, Levrotto & Bella, 1959.
  • EASTON P. D., EDDEY P. H., HARRIS T. S., An Investigation of Revaluations of Tangible Long-Lived Assets, Journal of Accounting Research, 31(supp)/1993, pag. 1 e ss.
  • FERRERO G., DEZZANI F., Manuale delle analisi di bilancio. Indici e flussi, Giuffrè, 1979.
  • GAEREMYNCK A., VEUGELERS R., The Revaluation of Assets as a Signalling Device: A Theoretical and an Empirical Analysis, Accounting and Business Research, 29(2)/ 1999, pag. 123 e ss.
  • IATRIDIS G. E., KILIRGIOTIS G., Incentives for Fixed Asset Revaluations: The UK Evidence, Journal of Applied Accounting Research, 13(1)/2012, pag. 5 e ss.
  • JAGGI B., TSUI J., Management Motivation and Market Assessment: Revaluations of Fixed Assets, Journal of International Financial Management & Accounting, 12(2)/2001, pag. 160 e ss.
  • KOSI U., VALENTINCIC A., Write-Offs and Profitability in Private Firms: Disentangling the Impact of Tax-Minimisation Incentives, European Accounting Review, 22(1)/2013, pag. 117 e ss.
  • LIN Y. C., PEASNELL K, V., Fixed Asset Revaluation and Equity Depletion in the UK, Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 27(3-4)/2000, pag. 359 e ss.
  • LOPES A. B., WALKER M., Asset Revaluations, Future Firm Performance and Firm-Level Corporate Governance Arrangements: New Evidence from Brazil, The British Accounting Review, 44/2012, pag. 53 e ss.
  • MELIS G., Strumenti per il controllo economico e finanziario nelle imprese, Giuffrè, 2013.
  • MISSONIER-PIERA F., Motives for Fixed-Asset Revaluation: an Empirical Analysis with Swiss data, The International Journal of Accounting, 42/2007, pag. 186 e ss.
  • MASINI C., La dinamica nei sistemi dei valori d’azienda: valutazioni e rivalutazioni, Giuffrè, 1955.
  • MURA A., EMMANUEL C., VALLASCAS F., Challenging the reliability of comparables under profit-based transfer pricing methods, Accounting and Business Research, 43(5)/ 2013, pag. 365 e ss.
  • MURA A., VALLASCAS F., EMMANUEL C., I prezzi di trasferimento internazionali: un’indagine empirica sulle imprese operanti in Italia, Rivista dei Dottori Commercialisti, 3/2012, pag. 555 e ss.
  • MURA A., ROBERTO G., Nature and duration of the accounting differences between Italian and US GAAP, A case study on conservatism, Journal of Applied Accounting Research, 15(1)/2014, pag. 2 e ss.
  • NOBES C. W., A judgmental international classification of financial reporting practices, Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 10(1)/1983, pag. 1 e ss.
  • ONIDA P., Il Bilancio d’Esercizio Nelle Imprese: Significato Economico Del Bilancio: Problemi Di Valutazione, Giuffrè, 1951.
  • Organismo Italiano di Contabilità, Principi contabili, OIC 11, Bilancio d’esercizio - finalità e postulati, Giuffrè, 2005.
  • PODDIGHE F., CORONELLA S., Possibilità e limiti della rivalutazione economica degli immobili aziendali in caso di deficit patrimoniale, Rivista dei Dottori Commercialisti, 1/2007, pag. 19 e ss.
  • POPE F., Discussion of a Comparison of the Value-Relevance of U.S. versus Non-U.S. GAAP Accounting Measures Using Form 20-F Reconciliations, Journal of Accounting Research, 31(supp)/1993, pag. 265 e ss.
  • ROBERTO G., Le svalutazioni e le rivalutazioni non monetarie delle immobilizzazioni materiali, Aracne, 2004.
  • SHAPE I. G., WALKER R. G., Asset Revaluations and Stock Market Prices, Journal of Accounting Research, 13(2)/1975, pag. 292 e ss.
  • SZCZESNY A., VALENTINCIC A., Asset Write-offs in Private Firms - The Case of German SMEs, Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, 40(3-4)/2013, pag. 285 e ss.
  • TOKEY J. W., The Future of Data Analysis, The Annals of Mathematical Statistics, 33(1)/1962, pag. 1 e ss.
  • VISCO I., Considerazioni finali del Governatore sul 2013, Banca d’Italia, 2014.
  • VIVARELLI A., I Componenti Straordinari Del Reddito D’impresa, Società Editoriale Italiana, 1986.
  • WHITTRED G., CHAN Y. K., Asset Revaluations and the Mitigation of Underinvestment, Abacus, 28(1)/1992, pag. 58 e ss.
  • ZAMBON S., La riconciliazione tra principi contabili italiani e GAAP statunitensi: riflessioni su alcune evidenze empiriche, in Scritti di Economia Aziendale in memoria di Raffaele D’Oriano, Tomo Secondo, Cedam, 1997.
  • ZAMBON S., Locating accounting in its National context: the case of Italy, FrancoAngeli, 2002.
  • ZANDA G., LACCHINI M., Rivalutazioni dei beni aziendali ed utilizzo di poste del patrimonio netto: aspetti economici, civilistici e contabili, Giappichelli, 1993.
  • ZAPPA G., Il Reddito di Impresa: Scritture Doppie, Conti E Bilanci Di Aziende Commerciali, Giuffrè, 1950.
Chiudi [X]

Acquista l'articolo

Inserisci i tuoi dati affinché un funzionario di Giuffrè possa contattarti per perfezionare i termini dell’acquisto

Campi obbligatori*

Autori

👤  Fabrizio Piras
👤  Alessandro Mura